Skip to content
Bought & Held — Paid games, kept honest.Contact ↗

HEAD-TO-HEAD

Compare the receipt.

Four pairs that people ask us about most. Same money, different kind of evening.

Baldur’s Gate 3 vs Elden Ring

CHOICE OR MASTERY

9.6our verdict
ONE

Baldur’s Gate 3

One-time

Baldur’s Gate 3 asks what you will decide; Elden Ring asks what you will endure. Both are complete purchases with one large expansion at most. Pick the first for a group of friends and a long story, the second for solitude and a fight you will remember.

9.5our verdict
EXP

Elden Ring

One-time + expansion

Valheim vs Satisfactory

SURVIVE OR OPTIMISE

8.7our verdict
ONE

Valheim

One-time

Both are one-payment co-op worlds that belong to you. Valheim is about the group and the sea; Satisfactory is about the belt and the spreadsheet. Valheim forgives a missed evening; Satisfactory will still be running in your head.

9.0our verdict
ONE

Satisfactory

One-time

Final Fantasy XIV vs The Elder Scrolls Online

SUBSCRIPTION OR FLEXIBILITY

8.9our verdict
SUB

Final Fantasy XIV

Subscription

Final Fantasy XIV charges monthly and in return sells nothing else. The Elder Scrolls Online charges once and then lets you choose, monthly, whether the extras are worth it. Regular players save with the first; irregular players save with the second.

8.1our verdict
B2P

The Elder Scrolls Online

Buy-to-play + optional sub

Deep Rock Galactic vs Helldivers 2

POLITE OR CHAOTIC

8.8our verdict
ONE

Deep Rock Galactic

One-time

Two four-player co-op shooters. Deep Rock has no pass and a community that says thank you; Helldivers has an earnable pass and friendly fire that will end friendships. Deep Rock for a clean forty minutes; Helldivers for a galaxy that moves without you.

8.4our verdict
EXP

Helldivers 2

One-time + optional passes